Leatherby's Family Creamery

I almost always get the caramel craze because it's to die for. Homemade ice cream, caramel and whipped cream! Yummmy!

They raised their prices AND made their to go ice cream tubs a lot smaller than they used to be before inflation hit hard. Also I'm tired of ordering from here and at least 1 thing is missing and/or wrong.

Alan's Black and Tan is the best. Love the caramel and chocolate sauces.

The ice cream was half melted and turned to soup as soon as we put warm chocolate sauce on it. Should have been hot fudge not chocolate sauce. The ice cream was packed in a non insulated plastic hot dog container, which was very disappointing. Also only 3 scoops served for the Marie's Hot Fudge making that a VERY expensive order. Clearly not similar to the in restaurant experience!

I ordered banana split and it was not good at all. The chocolate ice cream was grainy, there wasn't enough topping, and the banana was very old, over-ripe and mushy, and the price was EXTREMELY high. YUCK!