Nicky's Ii Pizza Deli - Congers

I never like to leave bad reviews but this time it deserve it. Place a phone order for white pizza. Lady on the phone: what zise? Me:Medium Lady again: your name. Me:Maria Lady again: Brenda Me: Maria Lady on the phone: ok give us 10 to 15 mnts. I came to pick up my order and the handle my son a cheese pizza. Which I wouldn't have mind take it if kids like it but they don't. I come inside and said I gotbthe wrong order Counters guy ask who took this order and the lady with an attitude said I did repeat 3 times if was a cheese pizza. Next time don't use speaker phone. ?????????? Hello!!!!!! Who are you to tell me how to use my phone? Is not my problem you can't hear or see the difference between WHITE PIZZA AND CHEESE PIZZA. And on top of that getting my name completely wrong. Huge difference between Brenda and Maria. I will never order again.

--- **Restaurant Review** **Meal Type:** Lunch **Price Range:** $1–10 **Food:** ★★★★★ **Service:** ★★★★★ **Atmosphere:** ★★★★★ I had a fantastic experience during my lunch visit! The food was exceptional, earning a perfect rating of 5 stars. Each dish was delicious and well-prepared. The service was equally impressive, with attentive and friendly staff who made me feel welcomed. The atmosphere of the restaurant was inviting and pleasant, creating a perfect environment for a casual meal. I highly recommend this place for a delightful lunch at an affordable price!

Wonderful place to get food!! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

I've been living in Rockland since 2019, and I can't believe no one ever mentioned this pizzeria to me! I've missed out on their amazing pizza for so long! Unfortunately, I don't have any photos because I always devour the food before I remember to take any, haha. The VadkaRita is absolutely phenomenal, especially when you sprinkle on some hot pepper flakes and pair it with a glass of Riesling. Just thinking about it makes my mouth water! The salad pizza, plain slices, and grandma slices are all fantastic too. The atmosphere has that classic pizzeria feel, with square pizza boxes piled on the counter, the chef in his white apron busily at work, a gumball machine, and a cart filled with Good Humor ice cream bars. It's simple, but that's exactly what we love about it! A special shoutout to Mikey, who always gives us the best recommendations and engages us in wonderful conversations! I can definitely see myself coming back here every week.

Whenever I ask my son if he wants pizza, his answer is always, "Can we go to Nicky's?" We really enjoy their plain and pepperoni pizzas. The Chicken Parm is substantial enough to share between two people. On top of that, they serve Mexican Coke and ice cream, which is a nice bonus!