S J Pizzeria - Millville

Just ordered pizza and probably one of the worst pies Ive ate. Burnt, bottom, somehow managed to have uncooked cheese through out the entire top. Mozzarella sticks were still frozen in the middle, cheese fries were cold, and the 3.99 funnel cake fries for 3 fries. Spend your money else where.

All pizzas were delicious. While I would order the supreme again, just know you will lose your toppings so use a plate. Or wait until it is not hot and less will fall off, still use a plate. Also, pizzas not cut all the way, so had to get out pizza cutter to finish cuts to get slices. Did not receive our fried raviolis.

The pizza was really good and cheesy. Should have stuck with the Sicilian, though. Wanted to try round. It's not the same. Next time,they never disappoint.

Been going here since the 80s. To be honest I stopped getting round pizzas from them in the late 2000s because they dropped off....but not lately. Wow...have they returned to their 1980s form. The round pizzas are super soft with chewy crust and tons of sauce. S&J is once again the best pizza place in NJ. Been going there for months now and every pizza I get is PERFRCT.

I just tried to order a 12 of a party tray (listed on the menu) and was told they only have WHOLE party trays. LOL if you have the whole tray I'm guessing you have 2 half trays!! If you don't want to sell a half tray take it off the menu!