Elmar's Ny Pizza - Minneapolis

Best pizza in the cities, hands down. We drive from the east side for ElMar's. BBQ Chicken with jalapeños is our favorite, along with classic pepperoni. the watah!!

Always love ElMar's! I saw someone post on social media that they were doing bagels and I popped in there at 7:30 AM on a Thursday and got two bacon, egg, and cheese husband and I both loved them! they also had where you could buy just whole bagels, but I think they are testing out what they go with and when they do it. The day I went in they had poppy seed, salt, everything, and plain.Everyone here is always so nice, you still go in and order your food and you wait there a little bit for it to get done.As far as pizza goes, I've only had the classic and white pizza, they are so good I haven't brought myself to try anything else! Definitely recommend.

Heard about this place yesterday and being from NY decided to come out and try it. Loved being able to get slices (a rarity in these parts)! The pizza was definitely among the better pizza I’ve had since moving to MN in 2014. For me, Hello Pizza in Edina is still more authentic to what I grew up with but this was probably second or third (I would probably put Joey Nova’s up there too). The crust here is a little off for me but the rest is good and I appreciate the cup pepperoni. Worth a try but I don’t know as I’ll drive half an hour for a slice.

Could see it being a 5* if you 're from NJ or NY. If you don 't want to commit to a $30 pie, grab a slice. They are huge. Foldable. Not my favorite crust, but it is true to the style. Extra super greasy, which again, not much to be done about if you want it authentic , just be aware the grease may leak out of the box before you get home. Keep it level. Based on mixed experience, I 'd do 3.5 if it was an option, but 4 is more appropriate than 3 for a score. Staff has always been good, and there is often solid music playing. I 'm glad it 's there.

This is a solid top 5 NYC style pie! They have a dozen pies as slice options and also make full pies. We did the full cup char pepperoni which was extremely greasy but spot on for what we ordered. The crust is perfect and the sauce and cheese was the correct amount and paired perfectly with the crust. I would have picked a less greasy option but was out voted. Only complaint in the dine in is the plates were the paper style which is fine but these were bottom of the barrel and with the grease from the pie soaked right through to the table. Will be back regularly for slices but for full pies will avoid the pepperoni due to the grease. Highly recommended!