Jackie Reilly's Grill - Plainedge

On the positive side, the onion soup was delicious. Unfortunately, the corned beef sandwich was less impressive — it had odd chunks of corned beef instead of slices, and the rye bread was soaked through on the bottom. When they asked if I wanted it wrapped up, I declined, and my friend didn’t even eat hers. We didn’t receive any acknowledgment of our concerns.

Popped in today with My Great Friend Noel!! Sean Reilly and Jen the Bartender has been helping us out for over 25 yrs. The best!!!!

We were here for a birthday party. Just stayed chatted for a few minutes. Wine served was OK. Wait staff very nice accommodating.

My friend and I had the steak salad. The both of us said the same thing, way too salty!! My boyfriend ordered the fried fish, Horrible !! Drinks were warm. Fries were best part of meal

I had fish and chips which were both cooked to crunchy perfection. The owner personally came to talk with us and he is the best. Service was awesome.