Mikey's Pizzeria - St. Thomas

They can't deliver on time , Mike needs to hire employees who cares , was a big fan of his pizza ! Pizza Tonight are way better ! At least they deliver on time ! Sorry Mike , I'll never order from you again !

I definitely don't leave reviews often, but I feel that for my level of dissapointment it's worth saving others from wasting their money! Let's start with the outside sign not even being lit, when you walk in there's no overhead menu or pricing available so you're ordering blindly. They take cash only, and the staff is just unprofessional, flirting with eachother right at the counter like I'm not even standing there. I ordered a panzerotti the sauce wasn't even IN my food, it was in a cup in the box to the side. The ingredients were absolutely terrible. Mushrooms and sauce clearly straight from a can, cheese was like chewing on a rubber band and the crust was horrible. I also ordered a pepperoni pizza, the crust was thin, pepperoni was like rubber and wasn't fully cooked. For what take out is worth these days we usually finish our food but this was just force feeding ourselves. In the garbage it went. Never going back!

Just ordered pizza…. What a waste of money, I ordered 1 medium 3 topping and 1 large 3 topping plus tip came to over 50 bucks …. outrageous!!!!! I’ve had better frozen pizza from the grocery store. Starting with using canned mushrooms ?, cheap cheese, thin crust that was under cooked. Completely disappointed and will not ever order or recommend this pizza to anyone. Just another reason to quit eating out… poor quality for way to much money !!!!!

I've eaten at dozens of different pizza places, and I can honestly say without a shadow of a doubt, this was the absolute worst pizza I have ever head in my entire life. The pepperoni wasn't even edible. It tasted like it was under cooked. Very soft and no crunch to it.

Pizza was very lacking in flavor. Canned mushrooms are not ok on pizza. Cheese was rubbery. Sauce needs work. I hope the owner can find there passion they once had to make people great food.