Michelli's Pizzeria - West Melbourne

Ordered a pie tonight October 21, 2023. Was one of the best pizzas I’ve had since I’ve been in Florida. It was cooked to perfection. Also had the chicken parm with Alfredo on the pasta and let me say that Alfredo was out of this world! The girls at the counter were so kind and helpful. Looks like they are bringing back the dine in experience which I’m super excited for. If you’ve tried all the rest now try the best! I can’t believe it’s taken so long for me to find this hidden gem!!!

Used to be the best around the area but some bad changes happened over a year ago now in their processes. Good quality ingredients and unlike most, usually enough cheese and sauce. Unfortunately they just always undercook the pizza, very doughy in the middle and usually wet with too much liquid from the sauce, too watery. Not sure if its just under cooked or watery sauce or a little of both. Also, when this started happening the crust where it is cooked more around the outside is tough and chewy and the sauce lacks flavor. Too bad, we kept trying multiple times but this is consistently what you get for over a year now. May be a poor management decision to try and deal with their overwhelming demand and lack of staff with crazy long delivery and even pickup times. Prices are much higher compared to others too, which we didn't mind back when the sauce was thicker with flavor and the pizzas got cooked all the way. Hopefully the owner will actually address this for real. If they do, we'll try again as it really used to be much better than the other places here.

The garlic knots are amazing and the customer service is just as good if not better. Service: Dine in Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5 Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

Pizza is awesome. Cheese bread fantastic. Meatball and mushroom pizza was a hit. Found my new favorite and I’m a pizza snob. Highly recommend!! Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

They have the best pizza for 50 miles!! Meal type: Dinner Price per person: $20–30