Your Pie - St. Augustine

This has quickly become one of my favorite places to eat since moving to St. Augustine. The staff is always very friendly, and the food is excellent.

The staff moves gracefully to ensure your satisfaction is met! Give them a try; you won't be disappointed! It's a family-owned business that truly aims to succeed!

Since returning over the last few weeks, we've enjoyed one takeout meal and two dine-in experiences. Everything—whether takeout or delivery (I believe they use Uber Eats, although we haven't tried that)—has been just perfect! If you haven't given this place a try yet, I highly recommend you do. And if it's been a while since your last visit, I strongly encourage you to give it another chance. I rated the atmosphere a 5, but that’s specifically due to this venue's setup; it requires counter ordering, so don’t expect table service. While my husband and I didn’t use the restroom, we noticed that the place is very clean! They have happy hour deals for beer and some really great gelato too! Even if pizza isn’t on your agenda this month, the pumpkin gelato they offer is fabulous! You can also take home your choice of wine or beer if you prefer not to dine in. I should mention that both my husband and I usually order separate pizzas, and we often enjoy adult beverages and gelato, which is why I rated the food as I did. Vegetarian options: They have a wide variety of vegetarian options, and plenty of vegan choices as well. Dietary restrictions: They accommodate all dietary preferences, but if you have severe allergies, it’s important to inform them before placing your order to ensure proper handling. Parking: Being located in a strip mall, there’s always parking available.

Apparently Your Pie is now under new management and the pizza and service was excellent, not at all like my experience 4 years ago. It will become my goto local pizza shop. Well done !

I had the Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza and it was simply amazing, the service was great and love the atmosphere! Keep up the great work!